We have held a comprehensive research of one’s similarities of style and content between Baronio’s messages and the ones we’ll now ascribe to help you Vigano II, to distinguish such blogs of 2020-2021 from the different ones from Vigano I, of the many years 2018-2019
(Emmanuele Barbieri-Roberto de Mattei) Who is the actual author of this new blog site regarding Archbishop Carlo ? Why don’t we attempt to render a treatment for practical question that people raised during the Corrispondenza Romana ( here ), starting with a sure strategy: the study and you may review of one’s website towards the messages off most other article authors traceable on line. Just what within the scientific jargon is called stylometric lookup.
Well then, the research out of lexical and you can stylistic facets prospects us to merely one to you can easily blogger: “Cesare Baronio,” or “Baronius,” publisher and you will blogger, off 2010 to help you 2020, of the blogs Opportune Importune.
Prominent so you’re able to Baronio and you will Vigano II ‘s the software so you can progressives of your own terms and conditions “counter-church,”, “conciliar sect” ( here this is when ) otherwise “innovators” ( right here this is where ).
Vatican Council II is actually a couple of times eastmeeteast laid out from the one another while the a keen “idol.” To have Baronio, up until “the conciliar idol is overthrown, because of the disappointed recollections of the architects, it might be impossible to penalize brand new high priests that have besieged Rome to possess 50 many years” (, here ). Vigano II, in his recent Interviews with the Liturgy, and additionally describes Vatican II once the an idol and you can, particularly Baronio, establishes a Vatican II-Novus Ordo Missae equality.
” Vigano II produces you to definitely “the latest architects of these liturgy” was in fact “prelates have a tendency to guessed of owned by Freemasonry, notoriously progressive” ( right here ) ; Baronio in turn talks out-of “a rite composed of the notoriously modern and you will Masonic prelates” (, right here ).
The new courses of the the newest liturgy in order to Baronio is “printed missals whose form is actually regarding a good plotline to mention in order to to own versions on various federal dialects” (, here ). Having Vigano II, such liturgical instructions “are devised as the an outline, good plotline susceptible to just about skilled stars in search of social applause” ( right here ).
To possess Baronio “the latest offertory vanishes completely and also make means for a Jewish prayer having a good pantheistic taste” (, right here ); Vigano II describes this prayer just like the “Talmudic offertory” ( here ).
Baronio and Vigano II, when writing on the brand new Novus Ordo away from Paul VI, constantly discuss about it the latest “reformed rite” otherwise “Montinian rite
Based on Vigano “the fresh very-titled ‘Blonde chasuble’ about versions you to definitely preceded the latest Council, particularly in France, has become that kind of poncho which after the Council are enacted from for the all of us since a healing of brand-new means,” but is “an old in addition to liturgical fake” ( here ). Baronio typed one: “the latest conciliar chasuble is a beneficial horrid poncho who has got absolutely nothing to manage into the planeta revealed by the Saint Charles Borromeo (Instructionum fabricae, 1557), hence we discover represented in many frescoes, paintings, miniatures and you can enamels since Middle ages” (, here ).
Vigano denounces “attempts to make the reformed liturgy respectable which have objectively ineffective operations from maquillage” ( right here ). Baronio produces that “functions from ritual maquillage into Novus Ordo have been in all of our look at condemned from the majority of cases for miserable shipwreck” (, here ).
It’s possible to go on indefinitely, but what matters very beyond the verbal coincidences is the identical tone, hence expresses a great smug liturgical, theological, and historic degree you to definitely Baronio possess flaunted having a decade with the their blog site but is completely missing on the two years out-of personal statements because of the Vigano I.